SHB "Bang off" into tray of soapy water???

[Bees In Miami]

OK...I'm going crazy now ...  Going to do a combine tomorrow of a cut out that really had a SHB problem, and I could SWEAR I read a post on here about 'banging out' the SHB from the frames over a container of soapy water with 1/4" screen over the top.  It sounded extremely logical to me at the time, and I built my "bang out" trap tonight...Now I can find the post to reinforce what was suggested.    Ideas any and all?  Any help is appreciated!  Thanks! 

[AllenF]

Don't knock any bees in soapy water.   It's not good for them either. 

[Bees In Miami]

No worries AllenF...I made a complete 1/4" screen covering that kinda snaps onto the top of a plastic tub/container.  No bees in danger.      Anxious to see how it works.  Thanks for the reply. 

[AllenF]

Take pics

[Ray Bayless]

How did it go?

[Moots]

I'm I missing something or would 1/4" not be too big...hence, allowing bees through?

I would have though that you would have had to use like a #8 mesh (1/8" holes) to assure no bee loss!

[Joe D]

Good catch Moots.




Joe

[Ray Bayless]

I was thinking the same thing.

[vmmartin]

I did it with #8 cloth last year.  Worked pretty well but some of the beetles would try to fly off and I would have to grind their little crunchy bodies through the sharp galvanized surface of the cloth.  Which was really groovy.  IMO this helps to do a quick reduction in adult beetle population and give the bees a chance to get ahead of them.  The hive I did seemed to do better but still absconded this winter.